home > news & blog > blog post
How to Choose the Right Recruiter for Your Business
Finding the right recruitment partner can be the difference between building a strong team quickly and wasting months on poor-fit candidates. With countless agencies competing for your business, how do you identify the recruiter who’ll truly deliver?
Before reaching out to any recruiter, clarify what you actually need:
Volume and frequency: Are you hiring one critical role or building an entire team? Do you need ongoing support or a one-off placement?
Industry expertise: Some recruiters specialise in specific sectors, while others work across industries. Consider whether deep sector knowledge matters for your roles.
Seniority level: Not all recruiters are equally skilled at finding junior, mid-level, and senior candidates. Make sure they have experience at the level you’re hiring.
Timeline and urgency: If you need someone yesterday, you’ll want a recruiter with an active candidate pool rather than one who starts from scratch.
A good recruiter should be able to walk you through their approach clearly. Red flags include vague answers or a “spray and pray” mentality where they send dozens of mediocre CVs hoping something sticks.
Look for recruiters who discuss candidate qualification methods, how they assess cultural fit, and their approach to representing your employer brand.
Transparency matters. Whether they charge a percentage or fixed fee, you should understand exactly what you’ll pay and when. Ask about:
Ask for specific examples of similar placements they’ve made. How long did candidates stay? What’s their typical time-to-fill? Can they provide references from clients in your industry?
Be wary of recruiters who can’t demonstrate relevant experience or provide case studies.
Understanding their sourcing strategy tells you a lot about the quality you can expect. Do they have an existing talent pool? Are they actively building relationships with passive candidates? Or are they just posting ads and hoping for applications?
The best recruiters combine multiple approaches: networking, headhunting, referrals, and targeted advertising.
Support shouldn’t end when the contract is signed. Ask about their onboarding support, replacement guarantees, and how they handle situations where things don’t work out.
Overpromising: If they guarantee to fill your role in unrealistic timeframes or promise candidates they haven’t even sourced yet, be skeptical.
Poor communication: If they’re slow to respond during the sales process, it won’t improve once you’re a client.
One-size-fits-all approach: Your business is unique. Recruiters who don’t take time to understand your culture, values, and specific needs probably won’t find the right fit.
Lack of transparency: Vague answers about fees, processes, or timelines suggest potential problems down the line.
Pressure tactics: High-pressure sales approaches often indicate an agency more interested in quick placements than quality matches.
They ask as many questions as you do: Great recruiters want to deeply understand your business, not just fill a vacancy quickly.
Clear, honest communication: They’re upfront about challenges, realistic about timelines, and transparent about their limitations.
Evidence of sector knowledge: They understand your industry’s nuances, salary benchmarks, and talent landscape.
Focus on partnership: They position themselves as an extension of your team, not just a transactional vendor.
Structured process: They have clear methods for sourcing, screening, and presenting candidates.
Think about what model works best for your situation:
Contingency (percentage-based): Pay only for successful placements, but costs can be high and unpredictable.
Fixed fee: Transparent, predictable pricing regardless of salary levels.
Membership or contract recruiting: Ongoing support for businesses with regular hiring needs.
Each model has merit depending on your circumstances, so choose based on your hiring frequency, budget, and the level of partnership you want.
Beyond technical capability, consider whether the recruiter’s values align with yours. If you prioritise diversity and inclusion, do they? If work-life balance matters to your culture, do they understand that?
The recruiter represents your brand to candidates. Make sure they’re someone you trust to present your business in the right light.
Once you’ve narrowed down your options, trust your instincts. Which recruiter demonstrated genuine interest in your success? Who asked the best questions? Who made you feel like a priority rather than just another client?
The right recruitment partner doesn’t just fill vacancies—they help you build a stronger team, save time and money, and contribute to your long-term growth. It’s worth taking the time to choose wisely.
Looking for a transparent, partnership-focused approach to recruitment? Learn more about how Hatched Talent supports growing businesses at hatchedtalent.uk
You’ve posted your job ad across multiple platforms, waited patiently, and yet the applications trickling in are disappointing. Either there aren’t enough of them, or the candidates simply aren’t what you’re looking for. Sound familiar? The problem often isn’t the talent pool, it’s how you’re presenting the opportunity. Here are the most common reasons job […]
Choosing the right recruitment model can significantly impact your hiring budget and outcomes. Let’s explore the two main approaches and help you decide which might work best for your business. Traditional Percentage-Based Recruitment Most recruitment agencies operate on a contingency basis, charging between 15-25% of the successful candidate’s first-year salary. For a £50,000 role, that’s […]
